Club Honours

Hunts Senior Challenge Cup

Winners 2014/15 (Godmanchester Rovers 3 Yaxley 0)
Winners 2018/19 (Rovers 6 - St Neots Town 0)

Hunts Junior Cup

Winners 1929/30
Winners 1988/89

Hinchingbrooke Cup

Winners 2018/2019 (Rovers 2 - Pinchbeck Unites 2 [4-2 Penalties])

Mayors Cup

Winners 2019/2020 (Huntingdon Town 0 - Rovers 4)

Eastern Counties Premier Division Highest Position

Premier Division Runners Up 2014/15

Eastern Counties Division One Highest Position

Division One Champions 2011/12

Eastern Counties Premier Division League Cup

Winners 2013/14

Eastern Counties Division One Knockout Cup

Winners 2011/12

Cambridgeshire League

League Cup Winners 1994/5, 1995/6, 1996/97

Furthest FA Cup Round

First Qualifying Round 2009/10

Furthest FA Vase Round

Fourth Round 2018/2019

Highest Recorded Cup Attendance

252 vs Sporting Khalsa, FA Vase Fourth round, 5 January 2019

Highest Recorded League Attendance

170 vs Thetford Town (Saturday 18th April 2012)